on the politics of ordering seed31 January, 2011


It is January, and as a new gardener, this means I get to dreamily flip through seed catalogs and envision by garden-to-be.

seed catalogsI’ve heard great things about Seed Savers, so we planned on doing most of our ordering from there, but there were a few things, like rapini and shallots, they don’t have in their catalog, so we looked at some other catalogs as well. Fun! Except a lot of what the different catalogs offered seemed the same. And other similarities bothered us. For example, Henry Field’s website is strangely similar to another company’s, Gurney’s.  Curious. It turns out they’re owned by the same people, Scarlet Tanager, LLC, presumably keeping the two different faces to not bother the loyal customers of either.

Looking further into this, we ran across an article in a country magazine about how big business permeates the seed world, with many seed companies being owned by the same firms or getting their seed from the same places.  As people who spend very little money, we think hard about who and what we are supporting with each purchase we make. And there must be better options in the world of seed.

Which brings us back to Seed Savers.  They are a non-profit whose mission is to save and share heirloom seeds, bringing together a network of gardeners who grow gardens that preserve the nation’s horticultural history and share that inheritance with others.  They are based in Decorah, Iowa and use their visitors center there to educate and bring together community.

Rather than just ordering from their catalog, we’re going to join, and gain access to all the seeds offered by other members. I’m sure through them we’ll be able to find those few things that weren’t available through the catalog itself. And feel better knowing where our seeds are really coming from.


Comments

  • I <3 Seed Savers! We've ordered from them the last two years we've gardened. There's a certain cruelty and also hope in the catalog arriving in the dead of winter, though, when the growing season couldn't be further away.

    Elizabeth31 January, 2011 at 1:08 pm

  • Well put, E. Cruelty and hope.

    a31 January, 2011 at 2:37 pm

  • Cool.. I didn’t know about seed savers.. will have to get some stuff from there.

    I’m a pretty big Burpee devotee with some supplements from Park. Are either owned by holding companies I should know about?

    CJA31 January, 2011 at 7:54 pm

  • I don’t know, C. I would check their website and see if you can visit their nurseries (not that you need to actually visit, but just know that you could). They’re probably real places run by real people if they have real plants in the ground.

    a1 February, 2011 at 6:44 am

  • We have been enamored with Baker Creek Heirloom Seeds, despite our lack of growing space, in part, because they have a physical store in Petaluma that used to be a bank. They’ve kept a lot of the Olde Timey elements of the bank, so it’s Actually a Seed… Bank. Neat. http://rareseeds.com/

    S5210 February, 2011 at 10:43 pm

  • We’ve heard great things about Baker Creek! Their other location is in Missouri, so they’re also the next most local place for us. We’ve seen pictures of their seed Bank, but have never been. Next time we’re out there, we should check it out (as well as your studio!)

    A11 February, 2011 at 8:37 am


  • Write a Comment








    Notify me of followup comments via e-mail.